Police Misconduct

Police Misconduct Attorneys

Civil Rights

Overview

Have you or a loved one been the victim of police misconduct in Minnesota or the surrounding states? If so, the attorneys at Robins Kaplan are prepared to help. Our civil rights practice is known for representing victims of police misconduct in a wide range of cases. 

Our police misconduct attorneys have secured significant recoveries for clients across Minnesota, recovering over $130 million for civil rights victims and their families. Contact us today and learn how we can help. 

Types of Police Misconduct

Police misconduct can take many forms, and not all violations are immediately obvious in the moment. Understanding how your rights may have been violated is often the first step toward taking action. 

Probable Cause 
Officers may stop and ask you simple questions. Without probable cause, however, that should be the extent of the conversation. Officers may not then stop and frisk you or pat you down unless they have reasonable suspicion of criminal activity. 

Probable cause is also necessary when police officers enter a premises or arrest a suspect. They even need probable cause when searching a vehicle. Police commit misconduct when they search your property without your consent, a warrant, or probable cause.

Search and Seizure 
Police may seize illegal items and substances in plain sight. However, the Fourth Amendment protects citizens against unlawful searches and seizures. In other words, officers must have probable cause or a warrant to search and seize. 

If evidence is obtained improperly or if there is no probable cause of criminal activity, it can seriously impact a case. It also may be grounds for a civil lawsuit by the defendant (the citizen whose rights were violated in this case). 

Other Forms of Police Misconduct
Police misconduct and harassment types also include:

•  Excessive use of force
•  False arrest or unlawful detention
•  Police harassment or intimidation
•  Racial profiling or discriminatory enforcement
•  Failure to intervene when another officer violates rights
•  Deliberate indifference to serious medical needs

Of course, every situation is different and will rely heavily on the facts. Speaking with an experienced police misconduct attorney early on can make a big difference.

What to Do If You’ve Been a Victim of Police Misconduct

Taking the proper steps after an incident with the police can help protect your rights. It can also strengthen your case. Following a few common guidelines can help your approach. 

First, make sure you’ve documented everything that you can remember. That includes dates and times, locations, and badge numbers if you can recall them. Witnesses who were present at the time are also important, so try to get their contact information if you don’t already have it. Other helpful items include photos, videos, and medical records. 

From there, avoid discussing the incident publicly or on social media. Opposing counsel can take early statements out of context and use them against you.

Most importantly, be sure to connect with a legal team as soon as you’re able. A qualified police misconduct lawyer can help you understand whether your rights were violated. They will also walk you through your legal options. 

What to Expect From a Police Misconduct Case

Police misconduct cases are federal civil rights claims. They often involve complex legal issues, so while timelines can vary, they typically follow this general process: 

•  Initial case evaluation and investigation
•  Collection of evidence, including records and witness statements
•  Filing of a formal complaint or lawsuit
•  Discovery phase, where both sides exchange information
•  Depositions
•  Motion practice, including interlocutory appeals phase
•  Negotiation or settlement discussions
•  Trial, if a resolution is not reached beforehand

At Robins Kaplan, our team understands the impact of police misconduct incidents on you and your loved ones. We work closely with clients throughout this process. We provide our clients with regular updates, explain next steps, answer questions, and ensure you understand what’s happening at each stage. 

Why Choose Robins Kaplan

Civil rights cases involving police misconduct require trial experience and a working knowledge of constitutional civil rights law.

A History of Success
Our firm has handled high-profile police misconduct cases. The work includes several cases against the City of Minneapolis, including three recent cases against Derek Chauvin and prosecuting the violation of Justine Ruszczyk’s rights after she was shot and killed by MPD’s Mohamed Noor.

That broader accountability is central to our approach to these cases. As Robins Kaplan partner and civil rights attorney Robert Bennett has previously noted, misconduct is rarely limited to a single officer. In many instances, it reflects systemic failures. These are situations where others “fail to intervene” or report misconduct, allowing it to continue unchecked. The team at Robins Kaplan builds cases with that wider context in mind. 

A Resourceful Legal Team
Police misconduct lawyers Robert Bennett, Katie Bennett, Andrew Noel, and Lauren Roso lead the firm's civil rights and police misconduct practice. The team handles civil rights matters from initial investigation through trial or settlement.

Clients choose our firm because we offer:

•  A proven record of results in civil rights litigation
•  Resources to take on government entities and large institutions
•  Clear, consistent communication throughout the case
•  A client-focused approach that prioritizes both legal outcomes and personal impact

Experience

Ruszczyk v. Noor, et al.
Members of the Robins Kaplan’s civil rights team secured a landmark $20 million settlement for the family of Justine Ruszczyk, who was shot and killed by Minneapolis police officer Mohamed Noor after calling 911 to report a possible assault near her home in July 2017.

Pope, John v. Chauvin, Derek; Arradondo, Medaria & MPD
Robins Kaplan civil rights attorneys secured a $7.5 million settlement on behalf of client, John Pope, a victim of police misconduct at the hands of Derek Chauvin and other Minneapolis Police Department (MPD) officers. The lawsuit filed in Minnesota, alleging police misconduct, use of excessive force, and racial discrimination was filed against the City of Minneapolis, Chauvin, and several other MPD officers from incidents three years prior to the murder of George Floyd. On April 13, 2023, the Minneapolis City Council granted unanimous approval of the civil rights settlement.

Olthoff v. Warnygora, et al.
Members of the Robins Kaplan’s civil rights team secured a $6.2 million settlement for Shawn Olthoff, who was shot twice by a Carlton County sergeant while lying unarmed with his hands raised during a CERT team response. The shooting left Olthoff paralyzed from the chest down.

Ngo v. Storlie
Members of the Robins Kaplan’s civil rights team secured a $4.5 million settlement for Minneapolis police officer Duy Ngo after he was shot multiple times by a fellow officer while working undercover. At the time, it was reported as one of Minneapolis’s largest settlements involving allegations of police misconduct.

Nelson v. Kusick
Robins Kaplan’s civil rights team secured a $3.175 million settlement for a 29-year-old man who was shot nine times by a police officer while experiencing a mental health crisis. He suffered serious injuries requiring extensive medical treatment and multiple surgeries.

Castile v. Village of St. Anthony
Members of the Robins Kaplan’s civil rights team secured a $2.995 million settlement for the family of Philando Castile, a Black motorist who was fatally shot by St. Anthony police officer Jeronimo Yanez during a 2016 traffic stop after informing the officer that he was legally carrying a firearm. The settlement resolved the family’s civil claims and avoided prolonged litigation.

Yang v. Chadbourne
Members of the Robins Kaplan’s civil rights team secured a $2.85 million settlement for Shoua Yang, who was shot three times by a Brooklyn Park police officer during the response to a fight at a Valentine’s Day party. The lawsuit alleged that the officer fired six shots into a vehicle as Yang and his friends attempted to leave. Yang suffered serious injuries, including the loss of a kidney.

Stevenson v. Doe, et al.
Robins Kaplan’s civil rights team secured a $3.89+ million settlement and the award of fees for Soren Stevenson, who lost an eye after being struck in the face by a 40mm blunt-impact projectile fired by a Minneapolis police officer during a May 2020 protest. The federal civil rights lawsuit alleged that Stevenson was peacefully protesting and posed no threat when he was struck.

Sieff v. City of Chaska, et al.
Members of Robins Kaplan’s civil rights team secured a $1.75 million settlement for the family of Dawn Pfister, who was fatally shot by a Chaska police officer after taking a small folding knife away from a man who had held her hostage and threatened her with it.

Code v. Chauvin, Arradondo, Johnson & MPD
Robins Kaplan civil rights attorneys secured a $1,375,000 settlement on behalf of client, Zoya Code. The lawsuit filed against Derek Chauvin, the City of Minneapolis, and several additional Minneapolis Police (MPD) officers alleged police misconduct, use of excessive force, and racial discrimination against Code during a 2017 incident, three years before the murder of George Floyd.

Day v. Chauvin, et al.
Obtained a $600,000 settlement with the City of Minneapolis for client Patty Day, who was subjected to excessive force and a wrongful arrest by former Minneapolis Police Department (MPD) officer Derek Chauvin and his then-partner, officer Ellen Jensen. In her Complaint, Ms. Day alleged that during an interaction with police in January 2020, she was violently jerked from her car by Chauvin and Jensen and thrown to the ground, despite being no threat to the officers. Her Complaint further alleged that Chauvin then assumed his signature pose, pressing his knee into Ms. Day’s back while she was handcuffed. The officers’ use of force resulted in Ms. Day suffering a fractured tooth, along with significant arm and shoulder injuries. As alleged in the Complaint, officer Jensen did nothing to intervene.

Hovland-Knase v. Soppeland
Members of Robins Kaplan’s civil rights team secured an approximately $350,000 settlement for Matthew Hovland-Knase after an Eden Prairie police officer’s service weapon discharged as the officer exited his squad car following a high-speed pursuit, striking Hovland-Knase in the arm.

Read More:

Professionals

FAQs

What are examples of serious misconduct?
Serious misconduct violates constitutional rights. Examples can include excessive force, unlawful shootings, and denial of medical care.

How long do I have to file a police misconduct claim in Minnesota?
Federal civil rights claims in Minnesota are generally subject to a six-year statute of limitations. Deadlines vary by claim type, so contact an attorney promptly.

Do I need to file a complaint with the Police Department, City or County before filing a lawsuit?
While such complaints may be helpful in some situations, you don’t always need to file one. You can often pursue a federal civil rights lawsuit without first filing a formal complaint with the police department, city or county.

Type the following characters: foxtrot, tango, six, tango, whisky, hotel

* Indicates a required field.

Jump to Page

Robins Kaplan LLP Cookie Preference Center

Your Privacy

When you visit our website, we use cookies on your browser to collect information. The information collected might relate to you, your preferences, or your device, and is mostly used to make the site work as you expect it to and to provide a more personalized web experience. For more information about how we use Cookies, please see our Privacy Policy.

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Always Active

Necessary cookies enable core functionality such as security, network management, and accessibility. These cookies may only be disabled by changing your browser settings, but this may affect how the website functions.

Functional Cookies

Always Active

Some functions of the site require remembering user choices, for example your cookie preference, or keyword search highlighting. These do not store any personal information.

Form Submissions

Always Active

When submitting your data, for example on a contact form or event registration, a cookie might be used to monitor the state of your submission across pages.

Performance Cookies

Performance cookies help us improve our website by collecting and reporting information on its usage. We access and process information from these cookies at an aggregate level.

Powered by Firmseek