Significant Dismissals Filed in August 2014

Case Number Plaintiff Defendant Document Date Patent #/Title Dismissal
1:11-cv-02365-KBF (Dkt. 199)

Microsoft Corporation

Datatern, Inc.


5,937,402 (“System for enabling access to a relational database from an object oriented program”);
6,101,502 (“Object model mapping and runtime engine for employing relational database with object oriented software”)

Dismissed with prejudice declaratory judgment challenge to the ’402 patent
1:14-cv-04297-PGG (Dkt. 9) Hutzler Manufacturing Company, Inc.

Christmas Tree Shops, Inc.


D538114 (“Onion container”); D553443 (“Container”);
D562082 (“Tomato keeper”);
D592463 (“Garlic container”)

Dismissed with prejudice

1:14-cv-02182-GHW (Dkt. 33) James S. Chizmar

CCL Industries Corp.;
Avery Products Corp.; Staples, Inc.


6,371,678 (“Loose-leaf binder”)

Dismissed with prejudice

1:14-cv-04800-LGS (Dkt. 12), Inc. The Debt Exchange, Inc. 08/28/2014

7,526,444 (“Integrated trading information processing and transmission system for exempt securities”);
7,877,319 (same); 8,694,418 (same)

Dismissed without prejudice
1:13-cv-07931-TPG (Dkt. 23)

Softlines International, LLC; Emjoi, Inc.

Beautyko USA, Inc.;
The Body Source; ABC Corp.


8,551,117 (“Handheld exfoliating device”)

Dismissed without prejudice with respect to defendant IVOG LLC

The articles on our Website include some of the publications and papers authored by our attorneys, both before and after they joined our firm. The content of these articles should not be taken as legal advice.